Bagelicious in Suffern

Now Black Bear Inn or something. Keeps changing hands. No more bagels. Hours are short. Made it cute inside, but if you close at 6, or earlier, why are you selling pizza? This place was great before, but suffering under being sold and sold and sold and no one wants to extend the hours to make it so that pizza will work, and se...

This place is no longer Gianetta's or Patty D's as it changed owners again in early 2018. Unfortunately, the high turnover is indicative of the quality of the food. The current iteration of this deli is just as lackluster as the previous versions. Hubs and I ordered dinner from them a few weeks ago (chicken parm for him, Italian sub for me). My sub was "fine," but we ordered on a Saturday night, and my bread was dry and stale, disgustingly so. I don't know how old it was, but I assume it was sitting around from the day before. My huband's chicken parm was horrible. It had the same stale bread, and the chicken cutlet was chewy/rubbery. It would be nice to have a decent deli at this location since it's so close to our house, but sadly, we wouldn't return.

Popped in craving a slice of pizza. Ordered 3 of those big slices because I didnt want to wait around 25 minutes for a pie. Paid $13 bucks for the 3 slices and 2 snapples. Seems pricey since I really had wanted the $10 pie special they advertised. Get home, taste the pizza, it's tasteless. Decent crunch, nice and warm and tasteless. Added every spice that goes on pizza, still thin, crispy almost sauceless, and tasteless. Bummer.