The Rivers Bar & Supper Club in Amherst

Went to this Supper Club based on the excellent reviews to celebrate my Birthday. Arrived at 5:30pm, there was a medium crowd, three tables of two, one table of three, and one table of six. We each ordered a Crown Royal, my wife with club soda and coke for me. When the waitress took our order, my wife ordered the special, prime rib medium rare, baked potato, and and a salad; I ordered a prime rib medium rare, hash browns, and a salad. We also ordered four jumbo breaded shrimp as appetizers. The salad...

Great food and great people. My organization had our Christmas Party there last night. Outstanding. Hospitality, service, and the quality of food left everyone impressed.

We visited The Rivers Bar & Supper Club early on a Saturday evening for dinner.  We had a group of about 10 people, and they were easily able to accommodate our group; we were seated right away.  We had a pleasant dining experience with good food and good drinks in a classic Wisconsin supper club environment. There was only one gentleman working it seemed (other than whoever was in the kitchen), and he served both a few patrons at the bar as well as waited on our table.  We were the only party in the restaurant at the time, but I still found this impressive.  The menu was standard supper club fare.  Everyone in our group ordered the prime rib (except me), which came with a solid soup and salad bar.  We shared an appetizer sampler that included some good mozzarella sticks and jalapeno poppers.  I opted for the walleye sandwich.  Although plain in presentation, it was delicious and a large portion.  I went with the house-made fries which were thin and crispy instead of the frozen crinkle cut (someone in our group who tried both said they preferred the house-made).  My significant...